As I swatched Yash matte lipstick from Mickey Contractor, I couldn’t help feeling that the color was familiar. So I went through a MAC display and pulled every color I thought might be similar for a comparison.
Of course, there’s some difference in finish. Hug Me (a lustre) will be more sheer, and have a glossier finish. Blankety and Half ‘n’ Half (amplified cremes) will be creamier and have more shine than the mattes.
I think Cherish is the closest, in terms of color. It’s just a bit lighter and peachier than Yash.